Amanda-Users

Re: New to Amanda- discouraged by some absurd limitations..

2004-05-03 12:48:04
Subject: Re: New to Amanda- discouraged by some absurd limitations..
From: Jonathan Dill <jfdill AT jfdill DOT com>
To: amanda-users AT amanda DOT org
Date: Mon, 03 May 2004 12:45:45 -0400
Jon LaBadie wrote:

One of the concerns I have about disk-only based backup schemes is the
total loss of data.  If you encounter a 2-disk failure you lose not only
your most recent, but all your backups.  If a tape drive fails the data
can be read on another drive.  If a single tape goes bad, that is the
only set of backups lost.
If you're using multiple removable hard drives as tapes, I think that would mitigate the risk somewhat vs. disks that are "online" all the time, although spin-up seems to be THE most crucial moment in the life of any disk drive. I think disks still aren't as reliable as tapes in terms of failure rates, but would expect a removable hard drive solution to fall somewhere between full-time disk drives and tapes.

--jonathan