Bacula-users

Re: [Bacula-users] Time for change

2008-12-10 13:47:06
Subject: Re: [Bacula-users] Time for change
From: thing <thing AT thing.dyndns DOT org>
To: bacula-users AT lists.sf DOT net
Date: Thu, 11 Dec 2008 07:44:17 +1300
Lukasz Szybalski wrote:
On Tue, Dec 9, 2008 at 1:04 PM, John Drescher <drescherjm AT gmail DOT com> wrote:
  
So what do you think a reasonable cpu for bacula would be?

      
Depends on what level of performance you are looking for. My director
is a 2 processor 2GHz opteron machine (circa 2003) with 4 GB of memory
and 18 or so  x 250 GB SATA 1 drives in raid 6. My main storage daemon
is on a second machine with the same cpus and ram but only 5 x 250 GB
SATA drives and the storage is a 2 drive x 24 slot LTO 2 autochanger.
Right now the bacula database is on that machine but it has been on
yet another machine. On top of that a typical SATA fileserver will be
a desktop class 2.5GHz Athlon X2  with 4 or 8GB of memory and 5 to 10
750 GB Segate SATA2 drives in raid 6 using mostly the motherboard sata
ports. This type of machine will net 300MB/s writes and even higher
reads in xfs. At 300 MB/s writes the cpu usage never goes above 7% for
the raid under normal conditions. Replacing a drive will make it go to
around 20% of 1 cpu until the drive is re synced.

    
I would go with software raid, no need to spend extra money unless you
already have one, then go ahead.

See/compare some performance statistics and functionality like swap drives:
http://lucasmanual.com/mywiki/Bacula#head-3ad60a172345da090bfbaa9488f8f9e6b88722b8

Also if you are going with hardware raid will you be using SAS which
supports (SAS + SATA connectors) or just SATA?

I'm not sure about ubuntu, but if you are installing debian you can
setup raid right there, during installation. It was fairly easy. After
that bacula setup and you are ready to go.
It would seem to me anything over 2004 pentium 4 should be enough. The
biggest question is: does the pc you want to purchase has enough space
to fit let say 4 hdd and does the motherboard supports these many hard
drives connectors.

Do people have recommendation on that? I actually would like to add a
5th 500gb drive to my raid but I have no space for it.

Thanks,
Lucas
  

I use an Antec 900 case as has 3 x 5.25inch triple bays, so thats 9 disks plus then 3 single bays, so a dvd bay and 2 boot disk bays in which I have placed  a  dual scsi bay unit...(There is now an antec 1200 case which has an extra triple bay I think). My Motherboard is an ASUS p35 with 6 sata plus 2 esata....I run the dvd off the ide channel..one triple bay was removed and a 5 bay scsi tray unit installed, so I have 2 scsi disks as the OS raid1 (in the dual scsi bay) and three scsi R5 as the primary data (so I can add two more but scsi are too expensive)...then another scsi raid card powers the 6 bay external scsi disk pack, that is a R5(4+1) of 146s for more data the 6th is my restore disk..(146gb scsi).  I plan to have 2 x 1tB for data as expansion as needed on the dual esata and  the other 6 internal internal could be (2 at the moment) 1Tb disks mounted one at a time to backup to...Tape back up is to a scsi powered 2 x DLTiv 75 unit...I dont use it much though too manual...considering using single external 1tb fwire attached disks instead.

There is also a Corsair 3 x 5.25inch bay unit that holds 4 disk per unit, so I could run 13 internal disks, 2 external disks and 2 for the OS...

:)

On the Antec, each bay has a 120mm fan in front of it and the case has a 120mm fan at the back plus a 200mm fan at the top rear....I run them all at slow speed and there is little (fan) noise, the scsi disks whine noticably though (10,000rpm). At the moment I have a 520HX Corsair PSU, high efficiency and a 5 year warrantee...it sits at the bottom of the case so air gets drawn over the pci[e] slots, it seems to run at min fan speed so cant be stretched the raid cards have the spare ASUS chipset fans over them attached to the motherboard...looking at the 600HX unit when I add more disks though (the psu will then also be 3 years old)...I run a pci graphics card so the 2 x 16 pci-e are free for sata/sas controllers...

The Antec 900 I got on special...pleased with it...should last years with hardware refreshes every so often...oh the CPU is a dual core cerelon at 1.6Ghz and 2.5gb ram about to become 4, I can fit 8 but 2.5 seems enough, I just happen to have 2 more sitting around so it goes in when I next add more disks.

regards

Steven




------------------------------------------------------------------------------
SF.Net email is Sponsored by MIX09, March 18-20, 2009 in Las Vegas, Nevada.
The future of the web can't happen without you.  Join us at MIX09 to help
pave the way to the Next Web now. Learn more and register at
http://ad.doubleclick.net/clk;208669438;13503038;i?http://2009.visitmix.com/
_______________________________________________
Bacula-users mailing list
Bacula-users AT lists.sourceforge DOT net
https://lists.sourceforge.net/lists/listinfo/bacula-users