Leslie, The problem is not really about the correct discovery of the
devices. We have snmp access and are able to see the interface tables. The
main problem is with some of the addresses changing side and not being able
to see it correctly in Netview as the hostname is the same in the two
devices of the pair. Unless we do a nmdemandpoll to correct the situation,
the failover cause some of the already discovered addresses to be
discovered again in the other device.

Salutations, / Regards,

Francois Le Hir
Network Projects & Consulting Services
IBM Global Services
Phone: (514) 964 2145


                                                                           
             Leslie Clark                                                  
             <lclark AT us.ibm DOT co                                           
  
             m>                                                         To 
             Sent by:                  nv-l AT lists.us.ibm DOT com             
  
             owner-nv-l@lists.                                          cc 
             us.ibm.com                                                    
                                                                   Subject 
                                       Re: [nv-l] Cisco PIX / Firewall     
             09/20/2004 06:22          switch module in Netview            
             PM                                                            
                                                                           
                                                                           
             Please respond to                                             
                   nv-l                                                    
                                                                           
                                                                           





Francois, I have not run across this, but I wonder if it would be possible
(or helpful) to discover the devices by those stateful interface by doing
loadhosts (without the small p) listing also the inside address? If name
resolution was associated with the address that does not change, I wonder
if that might help with one part of the problem.


Cordially,

Leslie A. Clark
IBM Global Services - Systems Mgmt & Networking
Detroit


                                                                           
 Francois Le Hir                                                           
 <flehir AT ca.ibm DOT com>                                                     
  
 Sent by:                                                               To 
 owner-nv-l AT lists.us.ibm DOT com              nv-l AT lists.us.ibm DOT com   
         
                                                                        cc 
                                                                           
 09/20/2004 05:21 PM                                               Subject 
                                          [nv-l] Cisco PIX / Firewall      
                                          switch module in Netview         
        Please respond to                                                  
               nv-l                                                        
                                                                           
                                                                           
                                                                           
                                                                           
                                                                           









I am wondering what the best practice is for managing Cisco firewalls with
statefull and/or failover interfaces.

Theses firewalls work in pair with a primary and a secondary. When there is
a failover, all the interfaces of the primary end up in the secondary and
all the interfaces of the secondary end up in the primary. Except that the
statefull/failover interfaces stay in the original device.
The way this is seen by Netview is that the statefull/failover interface
looks like it is the one changing side as the selection name of the devices
do not change in Netview.

To add to the difficulty, theses statefull/failover interfaces are not
reachable directly. Only the inside interface can be pinged by Netview and
we configure netmon.seed to monitor the whole device with snmp so that we
get the status of all the interfaces. Also the two devices in the pair
share the same configuration. That means that they have the same hostname
and there seams to be no other way to configure it.

I tried configuring Netview with theses interfaces as HSRP in netmon.seed
(%) but because the hostname of the two devices is the same I know it can
not work correctly. The way it eventually end up is with both
statefull/failover in both devices (like a duplicate IP).

any idea on how to handle this ?

more specifically:
- do you configure theses interfaces as HSRP in netmon.seed ?
- do you have the "S" flag configured in oid_to_type for the oids
(1.3.6.1.4.1.9.1.392, 1.3.6.1.4.1.9.1.522,...)?

Thanks,
Salutations, / Regards,

Francois Le Hir
Network Projects & Consulting Services
IBM Global Services
Phone: (514) 964 2145