Re: TSM and LTO Throughput
2004-04-23 17:59:17
This is an account of our experience
with TSM and LTO tape drives from October 2001. I posted some of
it on the list back then.
------------------------------------------------------------
I recently was able to experiment on
systems with beefy machines, EMC disk, LTO library, and Fibre. Despite
all this hardware, and despite all efforts, I was unable to get reasonable
performance with TSM backing up the file systems to LTO drives. I
tried backing up over the SAN with the Managed System for SAN client (Storage
Agent) and with the standard client to a local TSM server via shared memory.
As the attached table shows, backup rates for lots of small
files is abysmal, 3 MB/sec or less. The backup rate for larger files
was better, but still far below expectations.
Tivoli says that these rates are NORMAL.
Our analysis of this is that the TSM
client is unable to send data at a rate fast enough to keep the LTO drives
streaming. This is catastrophic for the LTO. LTOs are not designed
to be speedy when they have to stop, backup, and index forward, as they
have to do when not streaming. To stream an LTO drive, its tape heads
must be fed at 15 MB/sec. With drive compression turned on, this
means that the entire system needs to pass data at up to 75 MB/sec to EACH
drive. This is hard to do with most systems, getting disk systems
to move data at that speed is difficult. In addition, there is per
file overhead required for the file system and TSM database. It likely
to be a rare circumstance that will allow LTOs to stream with drive compression
turned on.
------------------------------------------------------------
The lesson is, with LTO-1 technology,
the entire data path must support the streaming speed of the tape drive
time the compression ratio or the drives are MUCH slower. The objects
per second rate needs to be low also to prevent gaps in the streaming of
data. I have found few disk systems which can keep up with a streaming
LTO, and then only with large objects (few objects per second). TSM
and the drive microcode have improved, but upgrading to LTO-2 is the best
solution. LTO-2 drives are variable speed and will throttle
down to match your data rate.
Orville L. Lantto
Datatrend Technologies, Inc. (http://www.datatrend.com)
IBM Premier Business Partner
121 Cheshire Lane, Suite 700
Minnetonka, MN 55305
Email: Orville.Lantto AT datatrend DOT com
CONFIDENTIALITY NOTICE: This e-mail message, including any attachments,
is for the sole use of the intended recipient(s) and may contain confidential
and privileged information. Any unauthorized review, use, disclosure
or distribution is prohibited. If you are not the intended recipient, please
contact the sender by reply e-mail and destroy all copies of the original
message.
STG46205
Description: Binary data
|
|
|